Our Books

Native Voices

Links


Merchant Services

Omega-3s: the Fat Everyone Needs

Submitted by BuddyBoy on Wed, 01/13/2010 - 12:21pm.

Article by Vesanto Melina MS, RD.
High fat? Low fat? No fat? What do we really need to know? For many of us, the message can be reduced to this simple sentence. Beyond the fats we need to eliminate (trans) or reduce (saturated), there is just one type of fat that we need to add to our diets: the omega-3 fatty acids.

There are two distinct families of polyunsaturated fats, omega-6 and omega-3. Both are vital to health.

Within each family, there is one essential fatty acid that must be present in our diet; from this “parent” fatty acid, other family members can be produced in our bodies, including longer molecules called highly unsaturated fatty acids (HUFAs).

The two families perform functions that are necessary and that counterbalance each other. Compounds called eicosanoids made from HUFAs in the omega-6 family increase blood pressure, inflammation and cell proliferation or division. Those formed from HUFAs in the omega 3 family protect against these responses. While we need the eicosanoids formed from the omega-6 family, when we produce too much, our risk of chronic disease increases.
One of the HUFAs in the omega-3 family is docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). It is an important part of the gray matter of the brain, the retina of the eye and some cell membranes. Low levels of DHA have been associated with conditions such as depression, schizophrenia, Alzheimer’s disease and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

We must get enough DHA either by making it from the parent omega-3 fatty acid or by getting it directly from foods. One direct source of DHA is fish; however we can also get DHA now from microalgae, which is actually the origin of the DHA present in fish. I find that some of my clients benefit from direct sources of DHA and recommend taking it in veggie caps as an optimal way to get this HUFA. (To locate sources, do a web search for "vegan DHA.")

A MATTER OF BALANCE

Our diets provide a multitude of sources of omega-6 fatty acids: all sorts of grains, seeds and seed oils, nuts, soyfoods and animal products. Omega-3 fatty acids are present in far fewer foods. Usually our diets provide 10 to 20 times as much of the omega-6s as of omega-3s. Experts recommend that a more ideal balance would be two to six parts omega-6 fatty acids to one part omega-3 fatty acids.

THE BOTTOM LINE

My co-author (and expert on essential fats) Brenda Davis covers these complex issues of dietary fats in our books: "The New Becoming Vegetarian," "Becoming Vegetarian," Becoming Vegan," and I do so in "Raising Vegetarian Children." Here are a few simple guidelines that can restore your balance.

1. Limit your use of polyunsaturated oils rich in omega-6 fatty acids and high-fat processed foods that are high in these oils. Oils that are high in omega-6 fatty acids are sunflower, safflower, corn, soybean and cottonseed; also check labels on processed foods for these oils.

2. Include good sources of omega-3 fatty acid in your diet. Rely on flaxseeds, flaxseed oil, hempseeds, hempseed oil, canola oil, walnuts and green leafy vegetables. Flaxseeds and flaxseed oil are by far the richest sources; one teaspoon of flaxseed oil or one and a half tablespoons of ground flaxseed can give your day’s supply; doubling this amount may give you a valuable safety margin. Other sources are tofu and soybeans.

Although balance-type-oils provide a good balance of omega-3s and 6s if they were our only source of dietary fat, they are not our best choice. Since dietary intakes of the omega-6s are more than ample, from our many food sources of omega 6's, we restore balance by consuming more of the omega 3's, which are present in relatively few foods.

FLAXSEED EGG REPLACER
This egg substitute works well to replace an egg or two in pancakes, muffins and most cakes and cookies. Instead of saturated fat and cholesterol, you’ll increase your intake of omega-3s. This won’t replace eggs in an omelet, quiche or soufflé though. Flaxseed oil should never be heated, however the omega-3 fatty acids present in ground flaxseed survive the baking of a muffin or brief period of heating of a pancake.

As an easy way to prepare your own egg replacer, blend 1/2 cup of flaxseed for about 1 minute until all seeds are turned into a coarse powder. If you prefer a finer powder, blend until the desired consistency is reached. Ground seeds can be stored, in a jar, in your refrigerator or freezer for several months; they will retain their omega-3s either way. In your favourite recipe for pancakes or baked items, use the mixture below as replacement for each egg.

1 tbsp ground flaxseed
3 tbsp water
Place ground flaxseed and water in a bowl. Stir and add to wet ingredients in recipe.

Vesanto Melina's web site.

Omega-3 and Walnuts

I applaud the authors for adding their voices to the growing body of work regarding the importance of omega-3 fats. However, a walnut is not the ideal poster child for this fat. There is a common misconception about the omega-3 content of walnuts, which readers would be wise to note.

Walnuts contain far more omega-6 fats (51%) than omega-3 (5%)*. What this means is that although walnuts are indeed a highly nutritious and healthful food, it's important to think of them as primarily a rich source of omega-6, and to balance them with rich sources of omega-3.

Since eating flaxseeds or chia seeds is not anywhere near as enjoyable as eating walnuts, the chances of ingesting enough of these rich sources of omega-3 to balance the omega-6 in walnuts are quite slim. Therefore, I would suggest a liberal and frequent intake of flaxseed oil in one's regular diet. (See my book, "Omega-3 Cuisine," for recipes that make this a pleasurable experience.)

I use Udo's Choice Oil Blends, because they contain both omega-3 and omega-6, in a 2:1 proportion, which takes the guesswork out of all this and makes my cooking and eating much less about the head and more about the heart.

This is not meant to refute the authors' remarks about "balance-type-oils." If we eat any amount of processed foods containing safflower, corn, peanut, sunflower, sesame, cottonseed or canola oil (high in omega-6; zero omega-3), it will be very important to tip the balance back with flaxseed oil. I'm comfortable with the oil blend I use only because I'm careful not to consume other oils, except for some extra-virgin olive and coconut (both very low in omega-6).

I hope readers will find this helpful.
~ Alan Roettinger

*Erasmus, Udo "Fats that Heal, Fats that Kill" Alive Books, 1993

oils

Alan, thanks for your comments. The high ratio of omega 6 fatty acid certainly is worsened by most extracted oils and processed foods containing them.

Because vegetarian and vegan diets also derive omega 6's from whole seeds, grains, and a wide variety of plant foods, they typically have omega 6:omega 3 ratios of 10:1 or more, even without high used of oils.

Thus the flaxseed oil or ground flaxseed are really ideal, which can effectively tip the balance in a helpful way. Yes, better than walnuts, which can help in a pinch. Good point!

However walnuts fortunately do have a higher ration of omega 3's to 6's than you suggest; actually it is just over 4:1 ratio.

Anyone can do a search (type in walnuts) on http://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/foodcomp/search/
and scroll down to the 18:2; 18:3 to see this.
Thanks for your comments, and for your recipes with plant sources of omega3's!

BPC Events


Queens Quay West
Toronto - Sept. 10th-12th

Portland Veg Fest - Sept. 18th & 19th

BPC Partners

Community